Estimated Time to Read: 8 minutes
In recent years, the debate over school choice has intensified across the United States, and Texas is no exception. Parents and policymakers are grappling with how to ensure every child has access to a quality education. Two prominent solutions often emerge in these discussions: school vouchers and Education Savings Accounts (ESAs). While both programs aim to give parents more control over their children’s education, they differ fundamentally in how they operate.
In Texas, recent legislative and political efforts have centered around implementing ESAs. However, many media outlets and opponents of school choice conflate the issues, often using the term “voucher” when referring to these proposals. Understanding the difference is crucial in today’s debate over education reform.
What Are School Vouchers?
School vouchers are relatively straightforward. Under a voucher program, the government provides families with a voucher or direct payment that can be used to send their child to a private school instead of a public school. The idea is to allow parents to opt out of the public education system if it’s not serving their child well, particularly in cases where local public schools are underperforming.
How Do Vouchers Work?
When a state adopts a voucher system, public funds that would have been spent on the child’s education in a public school are redirected to help pay for private school tuition. For example, if a state spends $10,000 per student in the public school system, a voucher may provide a similar amount for private school tuition.
Who Benefits from School Vouchers?
Vouchers are primarily aimed at helping low-income families or students in failing public schools access private education. Historically, these programs have targeted disadvantaged students in urban areas, where public schools may struggle to meet educational standards. With vouchers, families can choose private schools that offer better opportunities for their children.
What Are Education Savings Accounts (ESAs)?
Education Savings Accounts (ESAs) represent a more flexible alternative to vouchers. Instead of directing public funds solely toward private school tuition, ESAs allow parents to use the money for a variety of educational expenses. ESAs function like a debit account that parents can use to pay for tuition as well as other approved education-related costs, such as tutoring, online courses, special education services, and homeschooling resources.
How Do ESAs Work?
When a family participates in an ESA program, the state deposits funds into an account that can be used for a broader range of educational services. Unlike vouchers, which are exclusively for private school tuition, ESAs allow families to customize their child’s education by allocating funds for multiple purposes.
For instance, a family might use part of their ESA to cover private school tuition and the rest for tutoring or online learning. In some cases, unused ESA funds can roll over to subsequent years or even be saved for college, depending on the state’s guidelines.
Who Benefits from ESAs?
While ESAs may target low-income families or those in underperforming schools, their appeal extends beyond these groups. Families seeking a more customized approach to education, such as homeschoolers or parents of children with special needs, often find ESAs more attractive because of their flexibility. ESAs provide a way to access a wide range of education-related services beyond what is available in traditional schools.
Key Differences Between Vouchers and ESAs
Though school vouchers and ESAs are often discussed together, significant differences set the two programs apart.
Flexibility in Spending
The most apparent difference between vouchers and ESAs is the flexibility in how the funds can be spent.
- School Vouchers: These are generally limited to tuition payments at accredited private schools. The family does not control how the funds are spent beyond selecting the school. Once a school is chosen, the funds are sent directly to the institution to cover tuition.
- ESAs: ESAs provide much more flexibility. Families can use the funds for various educational services beyond tuition, such as tutoring, learning materials, and homeschooling supplies. This allows parents to tailor their child’s education to their specific needs, making ESAs more appealing to those seeking a customized approach.
Scope and Target Audience
- School Vouchers: Primarily designed for families looking to move their children from public schools to private schools, voucher programs often target low-income families or students in underperforming schools, giving them an opportunity to escape schools that aren’t meeting their needs.
- ESAs: While ESAs can help families leave the public school system, they are also attractive to those who want to design a more personalized educational experience. Homeschoolers, parents of children with special needs, or those interested in hybrid education models often gravitate toward ESAs for their adaptability.
Control of Funds
Another important distinction is who controls the funds.
- School Vouchers: Under voucher systems, funds are sent directly to the private school. Once the family selects a school, the voucher amount is transferred, and the parents do not control the money beyond choosing the school.
- ESAs: Parents have direct control over how ESA funds are spent. This allows for more tailored educational spending, giving families the ability to allocate funds toward different services throughout the year.
Accountability and Regulation
Both programs have oversight mechanisms, but the level of regulation can vary:
- School Vouchers: Private schools that accept vouchers must meet certain standards set by the state, such as accreditation requirements and some form of academic accountability.
- ESAs: ESAs can cover a wide range of services, and there are generally stricter regulations to ensure that funds are used appropriately. Parents may need to submit receipts or use pre-approved service providers, and the program may require audits to prevent misuse.
Potential for Innovation
ESAs tend to spur more innovation in how education is delivered since families can mix traditional schooling with online courses, after-school tutoring, or specialized programs, creating a more personalized experience.
Vouchers, in contrast, are tied to more traditional schooling models, and while they give families the option to choose a different school, they don’t inherently foster the same level of experimentation.
Recent Legislative Efforts in Texas Regarding ESAs
Texas has been a battleground for school choice reform, particularly regarding Education Savings Accounts. Governor Greg Abbott (R) and other proponents of school choice have been vocal in their support of implementing an ESA program in Texas.
The Push for ESAs in Texas
During the 88th Legislative Session (2023), Governor Abbott called for expanding school choice, including the introduction of an ESA program. His Parental Bill of Rights proposal, announced during his 2023 State of the State Address, included a provision for ESAs, aiming to give parents the flexibility to use public funds for various educational resources.
In the 88th Regular Legislative Session, the Texas Senate passed legislation that would establish an ESA program, but the measure faced opposition in the Texas House of Representatives. Lawmakers representing rural districts, where public schools are often the only option, expressed unfounded concerns that an ESA program could divert funds from public schools, potentially harming rural communities.
Having failed to address it in the regular session, Governor Abbott included the issue in a subsequent special legislative session in the fall of 2023. The legislation once failed in the Texas House of Representatives, leading Abbott and several special interest organizations to target those who voted against it in the primary elections earlier this year. As a result, nine incumbent state lawmakers chose not to run for re-election over the issue, and 15 incumbent state representatives lost their primary elections.
Recent polling has indicated that a majority of Texans support school choice efforts as well and the results of recent primary elections seem to support that claim.
Republicans have controlled the state political apparatus for over two decades, including every statewide elected office and majority control in both chambers of the Texas Legislature. The 2024 Republican Party of Texas Platform states,
84. School Choice: We support further empowering all Texas families to choose from public, privcate, charter, or hommeschool options for their children’s education and funding which shall follow the student with no s trings attached. We oppose regulations on homemschooling or the curriculum of private or religious schools and believe a constitutional amendment should be adopted accordingly. In lieu of funding, citizens may use property tax exemptions.
The Legislative Debate
Supporters of ESAs argue that the program empowers parents to make the best decisions for their children’s education, particularly for those in underperforming or overcrowded schools. They believe that ESAs can offer more tailored solutions, especially for students with unique learning needs or those seeking alternatives to traditional education.
Opponents, however, worry that ESAs could undermine public school funding and stability. They argue that without proper safeguards, ESAs might benefit urban families while leaving rural schools underfunded and unable to meet the needs of their students.
Conclusion: Why the Differences and Legislative Efforts Matter
As school choice becomes a central topic in education reform, understanding the differences between school vouchers and Education Savings Accounts is essential. Both programs aim to expand educational options for families, but their key differences reflect varying approaches to what school choice should look like in the 21st century.
Texas’ recent legislative efforts around ESAs highlight the broader national debate over how to balance school choice with the needs of public schools. As lawmakers continue to navigate these issues, the future of education in Texas—and across the country—will be shaped by how policymakers and voters resolve these questions.
Texas Policy Research relies on the support of generous donors across Texas.
If you found this information helpful, please consider supporting our efforts! Thank you!
