Estimated Time to Read: 5 minutes
Texas leads the nation in high electricity prices, a trend amplified by renewable energy growth, recent policy shifts under the Biden administration, and decisions by the Texas Legislature. With wholesale prices spiking 208% over the past three years, a growing population, and an aging infrastructure, Texans face unique challenges with the need for affordable, reliable energy.
Texas Electricity Prices: A Growing Concern
According to recent research by The Energy Alliance, Texas averaged $117 per megawatt-hour in wholesale electricity prices from 2021 to 2023, significantly higher than other states. This drastic 208% increase from previous years translates into higher costs for both consumers and businesses. Contributing factors include the Biden administration’s push for renewable energy subsidies, especially through the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022. Renewable subsidies, projected to average $25 billion annually until 2029, have driven a significant increase in the amount of wind and solar energy on the national grid, including in Texas.
“The reasons for the higher prices are not surprising,” said Bill Peacock, Policy Director of the Energy Alliance and author of the paper. “Texas has reacted to the problems caused by renewable energy subsidies by giving subsidies to thermal generators rather than ending its own renewable subsidies.”
The Inflation Reduction Act and Renewable Subsidies
Signed into law in 2022, the Inflation Reduction Act significantly expanded renewable energy subsidies, tripling the previous annual budget for these incentives. These policies not only accelerated the shift to renewable sources like wind and solar but also increased the overall cost of electricity, making affordability a growing concern. Under the Trump administration, wholesale electricity prices were comparatively stable, but they have risen by an average of 72% during Biden’s first three years in office. The Act’s influence has been especially notable in states with aggressive renewable goals, including Texas.
The Effect of Renewable Energy Subsidies on Texas Grid Reliability
As renewables make up 17% of the nation’s energy production—overtaking coal at 15% and nearing nuclear at 18%—grid reliability issues have become more prominent. Renewable energy sources like wind and solar depend heavily on weather conditions, resulting in variability in power availability. Texas has responded by financially supporting thermal generators, such as natural gas plants, to stabilize the grid. However, Peacock argues that Texas’s approach of providing subsidies to both renewable and thermal generators does not address the core issues with grid reliability, which stem from an overreliance on renewable energy itself.
We recently wrote about a recent report by the Texas Public Policy Foundation (TPPF) that similarly insinuated that federal energy subsidies distort the energy market.
The Future of Texas’ Electricity Market
Texas’s grid is expected to add 58,654 megawatts of renewable generation over the next five years, with renewables anticipated to make up 98% of new power generation. This reliance on renewables could worsen the state’s grid stability challenges and increase energy costs. To address these issues, Texas has established the Texas Energy Fund and ERCOT’s Contingency Reserve Service, which provide financial support for natural gas generators to ensure a stable grid. However, Peacock warns that these measures may be insufficient if renewable energy continues to grow at this pace. He suggests that the state should consider reducing renewable subsidies to alleviate some of the financial pressures on consumers and thermal generators alike.
Retail Impact: Rising Prices for Texas Consumers
Beyond the wholesale market, Texans are experiencing these price hikes directly in their monthly electricity bills. According to the Energy Alliance, the average residential retail rate in Texas reached 14.57 cents per kilowatt-hour in 2023—a substantial increase of 22% from 2020. This rise in retail electricity rates affects not only household budgets but also impacts businesses across Texas, particularly small and medium-sized enterprises that rely on stable energy costs to manage operational expenses.
The increasing reliance on renewable energy sources, combined with the high costs of ensuring grid reliability, plays a major role in driving up these retail prices. While renewable sources like wind and solar may have lower operational costs once installed, their high initial infrastructure expenses and necessary investments to stabilize the grid during peak demand times add ongoing costs, which are ultimately passed down to consumers. The Texas Energy Fund and ERCOT’s Contingency Reserve Service, established to subsidize natural gas generators, are funded through tax dollars and ultimately impact consumer rates as well.
Additionally, Texas’s unique deregulated electricity market structure contributes to the retail price volatility. Texans can choose from various electricity providers, and while this model promotes competitive pricing, recent wholesale price surges complicate the situation. Providers who previously offered fixed-rate plans at lower costs are now adjusting their rates to align with higher wholesale prices, leading to unpredictable increases for consumers. Those on variable-rate plans are even more vulnerable, as their bills fluctuate month-to-month based on wholesale market conditions.
The burden of rising retail electricity rates falls especially hard on low- and middle-income households, which now must allocate a larger portion of their monthly income to cover energy costs. As electricity prices continue to rise, concerns over energy affordability grow, spurring debate on the sustainability of Texas’s current approach to energy subsidies and grid reliability.
Conclusion
Texas stands at a critical juncture in its energy policy. As the leading state in wholesale electricity costs, it faces unique challenges in balancing affordability with the goals of reliability and a burgeoning population with rising energy demand. Renewable energy subsidies have driven up prices and created new grid stability concerns. The Energy Alliance’s findings underscore the need for Texas policymakers to reassess the state’s reliance on renewable subsidies to protect both the state’s economy and its energy consumers.
Texas Policy Research relies on the support of generous donors across Texas.
If you found this information helpful, please consider supporting our efforts! Thank you!
