Estimated Time to Read: 5 minutes
Texas Senate Bill 2 (SB 2), filed by State Sen. Brandon Creighton (R-Conroe) and designated as a legislative priority by Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick (R), aims to establish a universal Education Savings Account (ESA) program in Texas. The proposed legislation would provide financial resources to eligible Texas students, allowing them to pursue educational opportunities outside the traditional public school system. School choice expansion is also a key priority for Texas Governor Greg Abbott, who is expected to highlight it as his top agenda item in his upcoming State of the State address on February 2, 2025.
Similar legislation has previously passed the Texas Senate multiple times but has consistently stalled in the Texas House of Representatives. However, with Governor Abbott’s increased involvement in recent primary and general elections, proponents are hopeful for different outcomes in this legislative session. Nonetheless, skepticism remains about whether the bill will garner enough support among House Republicans, especially those representing rural districts concerned about potential impacts on public schools.
Key Provisions of Texas Senate Bill 2
SB 2 introduces several key provisions designed to enhance educational opportunities for Texas families, covering funding allocations, eligibility requirements, and compliance measures to ensure appropriate fund usage. The bill’s framework seeks to balance accessibility with financial oversight, enabling families to utilize ESA funds for a variety of educational expenses while maintaining accountability through audits and reporting requirements.
However, concerns have been raised about whether the oversight measures are sufficient to prevent potential misuse of funds and ensure quality educational outcomes. Critics argue that greater financial transparency and stronger accountability mechanisms may be necessary to safeguard taxpayer dollars effectively and also express concerns that a restrictive oversight framework that requires the Texas government to pre-approve all spending decisions by parents will significantly restrict parents’ ability to choose providers and materials for their children’s education while ignoring more flexible standards the federal government uses for education and health savings accounts.
Eligibility Requirements for the Texas ESA Program
SB 2 outlines broad eligibility criteria, allowing all Texas students to apply, including:
- First-time students such as kindergartners and eligible preschoolers.
- Students currently enrolled in public schools.
- Students attending private or home schools.
If applications exceed available spots, the bill prioritizes students who have previously attended public school, with up to 80% of positions allocated to those from low-income households or students with disabilities. The remaining slots will be distributed via a lottery system, ensuring equitable access while directing resources to those with the greatest financial or educational need.
ESA Funding and Allocation Structure
Under SB 2, students accepted into the program will receive a minimum annual credit of $2,000, with higher allocations for private school enrollment:
- $10,000 per year for students without disabilities.
- $11,500 per year for students with disabilities.
While the funding levels are higher than in previous proposals, experts such as Dr. Vance Ginn, President of Ginn Economic Consulting and a Texas Policy Research board member, argue that the allocations may still fall short in covering the full cost of private schooling. Dr. Ginn has advocated for an increase to $12,000 per student and additional flexibility to ensure that families can meet their unique educational needs.
Critics of SB 2 point out that the bill’s funding distribution allocates $5 billion to public schools compared to $1 billion for the ESA program, raising questions about whether the initiative will sufficiently address the broader challenges within Texas’ education finance system.
Program Oversight and Anti-Fraud Measures
To ensure program integrity, SB 2 mandates strict oversight by the Texas Comptroller, including:
- Pre-approval and certification of educational providers and vendors.
- Routine audits conducted by private entities to detect financial irregularities.
- The ability to suspend or close accounts for misuse and recover funds.
Despite these measures, concerns persist about the potential for fraud and misuse. Some policy analysts argue that additional safeguards should be implemented to prevent abuse and ensure funds are used for legitimate educational purposes.
Approved Educational Expenses Under SB 2
The bill specifies a broad range of approved educational expenses, including:
- Tuition and fees for private schools and higher education institutions.
- Industry certification programs.
- Instructional materials and textbooks.
- Educational therapies and special services.
- Transportation services related to schooling.
Challenges and Policy Considerations
While proponents of SB 2 emphasize that ESAs empower parents and provide more educational choices, critics warn that the initiative could divert resources from public schools, particularly in rural areas where educational options are limited. Additionally, opponents argue that without clear academic performance standards and safeguards, the program may fail to deliver on its promises.
Texans’ Growing Support for School Choice
Recent polling indicates strong public support for school choice programs like Education Savings Accounts (ESAs) and school vouchers, with bipartisan backing. A significant majority of Texans believe in empowering parents with the flexibility to choose the best educational path for their children.
Proponents argue that expanding school choice enhances student outcomes and ensures funding follows the child, rather than being restricted to specific institutions. However, opponents question the long-term sustainability of such programs and their impact on public school funding.
Legislative Outlook and Next Steps for SB 2
SB 2 represents a pivotal moment in Texas education policy, with far-reaching implications for public school funding and student enrollment trends. The bill is set for a public hearing in the Senate Education K-16 Committee in late January, where lawmakers will further deliberate its potential impact on the state’s education system and budget.
If passed, the Education Savings Account program could take effect in the 2026-2027 school year, offering Texas families expanded educational opportunities and greater flexibility in pursuing personalized learning solutions. However, significant legislative hurdles remain, and the bill’s fate will ultimately hinge on the Texas House’s willingness to embrace Governor Abbott’s school choice agenda.
Texas Policy Research relies on the support of generous donors across Texas.
If you found this information helpful, please consider supporting our efforts! Thank you!
