Estimated Time to Read: 9 minutes
In Texas, the practice of taxpayer-funded lobbying has become a growing concern among citizens who believe that their tax dollars should not be used to fund activities that may not align with their values or interests. Taxpayer-funded lobbying occurs when government entities, such as school districts and municipalities, use public funds to hire lobbyists (or consultants) who advocate on their behalf at the Texas Legislature. This practice raises significant ethical concerns and undermines the trust between the government and the people it is supposed to serve.
Recent examples, such as Texas school board members being advised to “utilize compensation as a weapon,” highlight how taxpayer dollars can be misused for lobbying efforts that may not reflect the will of the taxpayers. As discussed in an article by the Texas Public Policy Foundation, this advice encourages school board members to leverage taxpayer funds to influence policy decisions in ways that may not be transparent or accountable to the public.
The growing scrutiny of taxpayer-funded lobbying has led to an increasing push to ban the practice entirely. This movement is gaining momentum as more people recognize the inherent conflicts of interest and misallocation of resources that taxpayer-funded lobbying represents.
The Problem with Taxpayer-Funded Lobbying
Taxpayer-funded lobbying is problematic for several reasons:
- Conflict of Interest: Government entities using public funds to lobby for their own interests creates a conflict of interest. The government is supposed to represent the people, not use their money to further its own agendas. This can lead to decisions that prioritize government interests over the needs and desires of the people.
- Lack of Transparency: Taxpayer-funded lobbying often occurs with little transparency or accountability. Taxpayers may be unaware that their money is being used to fund lobbying efforts or what those efforts are advocating for. This lack of transparency undermines the democratic process and prevents taxpayers from holding their government accountable.
- Misallocation of Resources: When taxpayer dollars are diverted to lobbying efforts, less money is available for the services that taxpayers expect to be funded. This misallocation of resources can have a detrimental impact on communities where the tax burden continues to grow.
- Undermining the Public Trust: When taxpayers discover that their money is being used to fund lobbying efforts they do not support, it can lead to a loss of trust in the government. This erosion of trust can have long-term consequences for the relationship between the government and the people it serves.
Changing Political Calculus Around a Ban
The political landscape surrounding the issue of taxpayer-funded lobbying seems to be shifting. The political and public momentum for banning taxpayer-funded lobbying is growing, with more lawmakers and citizens recognizing the ethical concerns and inefficiencies it creates.
Supporters of the ban argue that taxpayer-funded lobbying distorts the political process by giving government entities undue influence over legislation, often at the expense of the taxpayers who fund these efforts. As more Texans become aware of how their tax dollars are being used to fund lobbying efforts that may not align with their interests, support for a ban continues to build.
One key factor driving this shift is the increasing awareness of how taxpayer-funded lobbying can be used to maintain the status quo, protecting the interests of government entities over the needs and desires of the public. As more lawmakers respond to the growing demand for greater transparency and accountability, the prospect of a ban on taxpayer-funded lobbying is becoming more likely.
Some lawmakers seem optimistic about the prospects for the ban in the upcoming 89th Legislative Session. State Rep. Briscoe Cain (R-Deer Park) recently took to Twitter/X to express his confidence. State Rep. Dustin Burrows (R-Lubbock), who notably is also the Chairman of the House Calendars Committee, similarly stated, “Show me voting aye.”
Recent Legislative History
In the 88th Legislative Session (2023), Senate Bill 175, aimed at banning taxpayer-funded lobbying, was introduced by State Sen. Mayes Middleton (R-Galveston). However, it failed to pass in the Texas House. Though it passed the Texas Senate early in the session, it was never granted a public hearing in the House State Affairs Committee, effectively ending its legislative prospects. It is worth noting that the committee is chaired by State Rep. Todd Hunter (R-Corpus Christi), who had previously voted against similar legislation in preceding sessions. Similarly, the companion legislation, House Bill 3538, authored by State Rep. Ellen Troxclair (R-Lakeway), was also never granted a hearing in the same committee, despite being referred there early in the session.
In the 87th Legislative Session (2021), Middleton, then a State Representative, filed the same legislation. It never received a public hearing in the House State Affairs Committee. The companion legislation, authored by State Sen. Bob Hall (R-Edgewood), also never received a hearing in the Senate State Affairs Committee. Instead, Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick (R) prioritized different legislation authored by State Sen. Paul Bettencourt (R-Houston), which focused on local jurisdictions only. It passed the Texas Senate and also passed the Texas House State Affairs Committee, albeit with several loopholes, and ultimately met its demise in the overall Texas House of Representatives as the House Sponsor, then-State Rep. Chris Paddie (R-Marshall), delayed the reconfigured legislation beyond a key deadline. Paddie chose not to run for re-election.
In the 86th Legislative Session (2019), Middleton again filed the same legislation. Notably, it passed the House State Affairs Committee, which had a different chairman, State Rep. Dade Phelan (R-Beaumont), who is now Speaker of the Texas House. Phelan was also signed on as a joint author of the legislation, but it failed to move beyond the House Calendars Committee, then chaired by State Rep. Four Price (R-Amarillo).
It is also worth noting that Texas Gov. Greg Abbott (R) has previously expressed support for banning the practice. In 2013, he spoke on the issue at a Northeast Tarrant County TEA Party meeting and reiterated his stance in a 2020 Twitter/X post.
The Case for a Ban
Given the ethical concerns and negative consequences associated with taxpayer-funded lobbying, many argue that the practice should be banned entirely. A ban would help restore trust in the government and ensure that public funds are used for their intended purpose: serving the public good. Here are some key reasons why a ban on taxpayer-funded lobbying is necessary:
- Protecting the Integrity of the Democratic Process: A ban on taxpayer-funded lobbying would prevent government entities from using public funds to influence policy decisions. This would help ensure that the democratic process remains fair and transparent, with decisions being made based on the will of the people rather than the interests of government entities.
- Ensuring Accountability: By banning taxpayer-funded lobbying, taxpayers can be assured that their money is being used for the public good rather than being diverted to lobbying efforts. This would help increase transparency and accountability in government, allowing taxpayers to see exactly how their money is being spent.
- Preventing the Misuse of Public Funds: A ban would prevent the misallocation of public funds to lobbying efforts, ensuring that taxpayer dollars are used to fund essential services like education, healthcare, and public safety. This would help ensure that public resources are used efficiently and effectively, benefiting all Texans.
- Restoring Public Trust: By banning taxpayer-funded lobbying, the government can take a significant step toward restoring public trust. Taxpayers would no longer have to worry that their money is being used to fund lobbying efforts that they do not support. This would help rebuild the relationship between the government and the people it serves, fostering a more positive and cooperative environment.
The Texas Legislature is majority-Republican and has been for over two decades. The Republican Party of Texas once again made banning the practice of taxpayer-funded lobbying a legislative priority at its 2024 Republican State Convention. It was also a legislative priority in 2022 and 2020.
“Prohibiting all forms of taxpayer-funded lobbying, including the use of tax dollars to hire lobbyists and payment of tax dollars to associations that lobby the Legislature.”
2024 Legislative Priority, Republican Party of Texas
Similarly, a ballot proposition included in the 2020 Republican primary election found that almost 95 percent of Republicans supported a ban. This aligned with 2019 polling conducted by WFAA and the Texas Public Policy Foundation, which discovered that nine out of ten Texans supported a ban on the practice. Beyond just Republicans, polling from the University of Texas and the Texas Tribune also found that a ban had the support of 69 percent of those who identified as Republicans, Democrats, and Independents.
Conclusion
The practice of taxpayer-funded lobbying presents significant ethical challenges and undermines the democratic process. By allowing government entities to use public funds to influence policy decisions, taxpayer-funded lobbying distorts the political landscape, erodes public trust, and misallocates resources that could be better spent on essential public services.
As the political calculus around this issue continues to evolve, the case for banning taxpayer-funded lobbying grows stronger. The growing public awareness and support for greater transparency and accountability in government make a ban on this practice both necessary and increasingly achievable.
By banning taxpayer-funded lobbying, Texas can take a crucial step toward restoring integrity in its government, ensuring that taxpayer dollars are used to serve the public good, and rebuilding trust between the government and the people it serves. The time has come for Texas to lead the way in banning taxpayer-funded lobbying and setting an example for the rest of the nation.
Texas Policy Research relies on the support of generous donors across Texas.
If you found this information helpful, please consider supporting our efforts! Thank you!
